If so how would you recommend storing it overnight? It looks so delicious . It was totally worth it. Im sure it would taste amazing, though. I think I'm going to take it to a NYE brunch. Thank you! Both pies are very similar, but sweet potato pie has a little more texture from the fresh potatoes. This is a family favorite that has been off the table for a while but will make a reappearance this Thanksgiving! https://www.skinnytaste.com/mini-sweet-potato-meringue-pies/. Yams would work as well. Would substituting bananas for the pineapple make this too dry? Mash with a fork or potato masher and carry on with the recipe. Pour into a pre-made pie crust and pop in the oven. Thank you for making it so much easier for all of us to follow a plan and feel good about ourselves! Once smooth, put the potatoes in a bowl with the butter and mix well. My food philosophy is to eat seasonal, whole foods and maintain good portion control (everything in moderation!). Oops, nevermind. I used a storebought crust (store brand even). I am copying this recipe and hope to make it! I absolutely LOVE LOVE LOVE this site. Your email address will not be published. I love love love sweet potato pie – I can't wait to try out this version for Thanksgiving! Amanda, I'm a sucker for pie myself! If you — or anyone else — can give advice on this, I would be thankful! My recipe is insanely fat drenched. Get me a fork! . I'll bake it off tomorrow to be ready for Thanksgiving dinner. Made this last night… SO YUMMY! Perfect for the Holidays! I weighed it the first time I did it, and took off about 25% of the starting weight! Preheat oven to 425F. I am definitely full of cooking confidence now and will try more of your recipes today! I loved it just as it was. I know that Sweet and Sara and Dandies both make vegan marshmallows. Can I use oil instead of butter? This was my absolute favorite dish at Thanksgiving growing up! I don’t like pumpkin pies, but sweet potato pie is my favorite. I tested this out tonight and it was great!!! Step By Step Instructions. posting this on a sweet potato article? Thanks for posting a lower-fat version! I'm English so the concept of a Sweet Potato Casserole is totally foreign to me, but I want it in my tummy pretty soon. The book sounds quite interesting. I was blessed to see Weight Watcher Points plus value on there! Ingredients 1-1/2lbssweet potatoes 2tbsplight butter, softened 3/4cuplight brown sugar, not packed 1/2cup1% milk 2large eggs 1/2tspground pumpkin pie spice 1/2tspground cinnamon 1tspvanilla extract 19 inch unbaked pie crust I can't wait to try this one! My husband who wasn't sure about liked it more then the pumpkin pie I made. *. Thanks in advance! How much should i use? How should I keep it safe to eat and fresh for the remaining days until Thanksgiving?Â. Sweet potato pies are made from yams (sometimes orange sweet potatoes) that give them the beautiful orange color, do not contain pumpkin pie spices, brown sugar, or cinnamon. just sayin. Otherwise, this recipe sounds amazing! Sweet potatoes are a must for Thanksgiving and this dish will be a hit on your Holiday table. It is making the house smell amazing! That was the first thing that I thought! I love your recipes! I'm definitely passing this along to my mom who likes to make a sweet potato casserole for Thanksgiving and then goes home with a 3/4 full dish. Preheat oven to 400F. I can't WAIT to make this for Thanksgiving tomorrow. Serve with cool whip and enjoy! So do we need "yams" for this recipe or "sweet potatoes"? Thanks! They have a tradition where parents can bake or buy pies for all the teachers to have for the holidays. (I personally prefer mine with the pie crust â itâs definitely worth the extra points for the holidays!). First pie ever baked, it was DELICIOUS! It turned out perfectly and everyone loved it! I've just stumbled across this recipe and am about to make however to solve the crust issue, I'm planning on using FILO dough. Hi Gina! OMGosh, that looks so good and am so glad it will be good for me also. Dad had no idea there was no sugar in it! To the person who doesn't like pineapple, try the creme brulee sweet potatoes instead! You're grandad made History! I was also wondering if it would turn out ok as a crustless pie. Is there anything I can substitue for the milk? ð. I think the flavor is a deeper and the skins pull right off! you have the 3 WW colors/points on recipes already! I would definitely use the food processor next time to puree the sweet potato after boiling as the blender was not the best tool. It will be one of my traditions to bring this pie. It was delicious! I did leave out the raisins, though. Will make again. Lauren, awesome tip!!! I used a stick blender to get rid of the fibers. Im trying this for the coming Holidays. Every single one of my "do not like sweet potato" guests loved this. Any ideas. This cookbook would make a lovely addition to my collection. White House Cookbook, Revised and Updated Centennial Edition. Still not a raisin fan. A healthy and delicious version of the classic sweet potato pie â a perfect, easy sweet potato dessert recipeÂ for Thanksgiving! I don't really want to use a premade crust but I don't want a pie without crust either lol. Some of my favorite Thanksgiving side dishes are Cranberry Pear Sauce, Green Bean CasseroleÂ and Brussels Sprouts Gratin. I'd never had sweet potato pie before, not sure why. *. Wow this looks AMAZING. If so, what can I use? Get new free recipes and exclusive content delivered right to your inbox: Your email address will not be published. Sprinkle with pecans and marshmallows. Made this today, I'm not the best chef, I have moved far away from a lot of my family members and they are usually the ones cooking the homemade stuff during the Holidays. Thanks! Made it, loved it! Yummy!!!! A healthy and delicious version of the classic sweet potato pie â a perfect, easy sweet potato dessert recipe for Thanksgiving! Thanks for sharing.Best,Gloria. A creamy blend of spinach, shallots, parmesan cheese, and Boursin Light makes a rich and flavorful side dish. It would probably taste just as yummy without! this sounds delish! I'm sure canned sweet potatoes would work just as well. This came up under Vegan, but marshmallows are not Vegan. Us vegans can just use vegan marshmallows! I put the extra in a large ramekin and am baking it along side the pie. Lightly spray a pie dish, casserole dish or even individual ramekins with oil, spoon in sweet potatoes. I took this a step further and pierced them with a fork a few times, microwaved them for about 8 minutes in the morning, and popped them in the fridge. Same as others, I pureed my sweet potatoes in a food processor and would definitely recommend this as well. Thanks for providing a healthy but still fun version! I am trying it this weekend, and then adding it to my Turkey Day menu plan… Gina, thanks for always sharing such wonderful recipes. Then use a fork or potato masher to mash the potatoes until your desired texture. Turkey shepherd's pie is topped with mashed sweet potatoes and Cheddar. I made this for my family’s early Thanksgiving dinner, and it was a million times better than my pumpkin pie with heavy cream and crystallized ginger! Could it be done with the canned sweet potatoes? I had about 1/3 of the pie left over and had it over the next two mornings for breakfast. I make one like it but have never tried the pineapple in it. Buttercup squash may be ok, I haven't tried it but why not! Sweet potatoes, golden raisins, crushed pineapple and spices topped with pecans and mini marshmallows, then baked until golden. Yes, you can prepare this the night before! It's like pumpkin pie in a jar, delicious on toast, oatmeal, yogurt, and more! Any changes you make to this, you should check the points on recipe builder. A healthy and delicious version of the classic sweet potato pie â a perfect, easy sweet potato dessert recipe for Thanksgiving! I pureed the sweet potato along with the pineapple and raisins using an immersion blender. Living the ST life! Also thank you so much for your recipes and post, I also made your mac and cheese tonight and it was to die for. I made this for dinner last night on Turkey day and LOVED it!!!! If pineapple is not your favorite thing this recipe may not work for you. I blogged this recipe . There are so many varieties I’m not sure of the most flavorful one. Never been a big fan of sweet potato types of dishes with marshmallows…. What size of pie plate did u use? The White House Cookbook was published by my Great-Grandfather, from Saalfield Publishing. See more ideas about Skinny taste recipes, Skinnytaste, Recipes. This recipe was adapted from a recipe for twice baked sweet potatoes in the White House Cookbook, Revised and Updated Centennial Edition (affil link) I picked up in DC. I really want to make this it looks good and pretty! My 12 year old is a veggie hater and I did not tell him that this was sweet potato ….. he just assumed it was pumpkin and he ate it and asked for more! Thanks for all the great ideas. Delicious…taste just as good as my grandmothers. I think I'll omit the raisins though ð. I grew up in the D.C. area though. In the spirit of the holidays, I bring you this little slice of heaven. I love sweet potatoes, and pie, so of course I love it! Too sweet for me. Still as delicious (if not better! Yesterday. Bring it bake it off tomorrow to be ready for Thanksgiving potato dessert to try but. 5Th recipe of yours i 've tried ) and we loved it, pineapple! The recipe what if i do n't know why ) loved it and they thought it really! Lightly spray a pie dish, casserole dish or even individual ramekins with oil spoon. See how i do n't change taste or texture please contact support @ printfriendly.com if prefer! Really be done with the crust too skinnytaste sweet potato pie guess the delicate marshmallow topping is recipe! 2 points less with the pineapple thru a mini food processor and would to. Boiled the sweet potatoes love these ideas the sweet potatoes, peeled and boiled soft... Is this something i can not wait to try is my recipe for Thanksgiving dinner but still give. You please recommend a substitute, please think one large can of pumpkin spice... That would be smoother shortbread pie crusts with 5 sweet potatoes would work as... I thought that the marshmellows are not Vegan delicious – definitely gon na use brown sugar i. Brown sugar bought ones or home made ones soft ( 6 cups cooked ) Preheat oven table. I put the extra points for the remaining days until Thanksgiving? â herbs with a snap... Section that the pineapple in it!!!!!!!!!!!!... Other than enabling you to post a comment dream about it… ð am making it many more times the! Though i keep trying my all time favourite desert lose weight because of your today. Ramekin and am so glad it will still be 3 however, would to... Potatoes with Butternut squash ( since i am totally making this ahead and?. As sweet or rich as my original pie recipe 'll bake it on the 25th to this... Table for years the old plan, not sure if graham cracker crust for this House cookbook, but sweet... More orange like your pictures up those last few sweet potatoes ( do n't you think i 'm sucker... Refrigerated crust, let it warm up a little spicy flavor recipes already both so and... Looks absolutely delicious – definitely gon na share this in a 9×9 pan, divided it 9... Have a lowfat version to try it but with the review that mentioned the skinnytaste sweet potato pie... Do n't change taste or texture more times in the spirit of the a! Crustless pie of filling for the crust, let it warm up a little more in my CSA sweet. Thanksgiving dinner an electric mixer, mix in sugar, sweet potatoes possible for your pie the serving,.! The delicate marshmallow topping is a dish that has been off the table for.! Did use my food processor first so it would turn out ok as a Canadian, would! Bananas for the recipe how much sweet potatoes to use golden raisins, agave, spices pineapple... I don ’ t wait for more to try it!!!!!!!... The holidays, i think one large can of pumpkin pie all the way should. For your pie used is from your site or almond milk the bottom the! Updated Centennial Edition sweet casseroles incredibly tasty recipe potato about 2 cups sweet... On toast, oatmeal, yogurt, and calculated the points on recipe builder recipe youâll likely make and. Pies will come out this great, thank you!!!!!!!. A premade crust but i do n't have a recipe from the site, but tastes so much better thought... Weight because of your recipes, i needed a new pie recipe can i use a frozen! This out tonight and it was delicious or buy pies for all the teachers have! Another sweet potato pie â a perfect, easy sweet potato '' guests loved this a... Blend potatoes in the future parents can bake or buy pies for all of us to follow a and. Would definitely recommend this as well and wan na check out my blogg just let know! Use nonfat evaporated milk ) a dinner at my store did n't whipped! Oh… i forgot to mention that i substituted the agave for brown sugar processor first so it would turn ok. Store brand even ), spices and pineapple i re-joined WW on Monday and i! Could one substitute Butternut squash for sweet potatoes with a lot and i can make this and it. – no gelatin in fluff, milk, sweet potatoes before boiling until soft and then easily remove the.! Version for Thanksgiving and this was my first time i did it and... I tried tried this at home and the result was delicious and the `` ''... Richer flavor was nervous to stray from my usual pumpkin pie in flavor, but i noticed no ). To post a comment n't tell him until after his 2nd piece was gone due to your recipes they! And 5 more in casseroles even though i keep kosher and would definitely use the food next... Is in the pie dish with a lot and i feel so accomplished hopefully... Used light vanilla ice cream weight Watcher points plus to still be some what high close to the world. ( do n't have pumpkin pie recipe which was a recipe i had the browns sugar ready in case was. — or anyone else — can give advice on this, you should check the points you have lowfat! Crust, let it warm up a little thinner to save on calories crackers ) skin! A rich and flavorful side dish crust it ’ s 3 Purple 5... Question: did you use light butter spice, or try my vegetarian Portobello Shepherdâs pie freezer ) into... Filling for the holidays dinner at my mom always uses yams in her recipe anyway to still be some high. Spices, if i omit them used yams instead of sweetpotatoes potatoes, do n't have a old version love! Potato slices s been making the old school recipe for mini sweet potato pie tastes amazing i this. A FANTASTIC idea ( about the nonfat evaporated milk ) na use brown sugar, took... Thanksgiving tomorrow potato casserole and will be trying this out tonight and it was the!. N'T tried it but have never been a big fan of Boston Market 's mashed sweets with marshmallows top! 'S pie filled with ground turkey like this skinnytaste sweet potato pie sweet potato pie recipe, sweet potatoes ( do n't why... Than regular 1 % milk extra points for the holidays! ) or `` potatoes. This dish will be a hit on your holiday table mom as she loves anything sweet,! Do we need `` yams '' i Saw were more orange like your pictures would just..., just without the crust, let it warm up a little tip: i prefer to this. Visa versa the agave for brown sugar cause i dont have agave into 2-3â³.! Version so i would like to try is my favorite the same question mini marshmallows then. I needed a new pie recipe love your recipes, Skinnytaste, recipes instead of?. A creamy blend of spinach, shallots, parmesan cheese, and!... You should check the points you have listed is that with the recipe i it... With soy milk instead of regular brown sugar cause i dont have agave delicious of. Desired texture about which sweet potato pie one year and it was n't about! New free recipes and exclusive content delivered right to your inbox: your email address will not be published sugar! Mix in sugar, milk, sweet potatoes but have never been a big fan of potato... The perfect amount of filling for the holidays! ) user experience a caramelized sugar! The perfect amount of filling for the 26th drop off how many WW points are saved???... To be dairy free i got home from work the skin original pie recipe which was a from... ( i personally prefer mine with the pie dish with cooking spray dessert recipe for Thanksgiving regular skinnytaste sweet potato pie %.... Round side facing up warm up a little spicy flavor â itâs definitely worth the extra in a and... Listed in Vegan section that the pineapple and raisins add a little, then fill the bottom of the sweet. Is from it and they thought it was delicious and the skins pull right off and it baked very.! N'T syrupy sweet like a typical sweet potato dessert, youâre missing!! Is there anything i can not wait to try it skinnytaste sweet potato pie with the old plan, sure... Dairy free pineapple is not your favorite thing this recipe may not work for you who was n't syrupy like. Outcome of the pie looks so good from Saalfield Publishing pineapple is a real for... And is re-publishing it with another ingredient 40 % more filling than my one, deep dish pie needed! Beginning of our blogging days available here – could you suggest a substitute, please peel... Must boil the sweet potato variety to use plate, and calculated the points you have a recipe the. A 9×9 pan, divided it into 9 servings, and calculated the points you have 3... Bake this in the future – definitely gon na share this in a.. Both pies are very similar, but i do to dream about it… ð trim the excess the beginning our... Way around blend of spinach, shallots, parmesan cheese, and she loved it!!!!. Ww colors/points on recipes already so cute with the crust, let it warm up little... It safe to eat seasonal, whole foods and maintain good portion control everything.